When the Google Slap Hits.. As it Did this Weekend..
If you didn’t know, yes, some of us experienced one this last weekend; or maybe it’s not officially a slap (actually it took me a long time to even call these adjustments in the algo a slap, but since everyone uses it and understands what it references.. I guess I’ll fall in line
),
Whether it is or not, it’s at the very least a knock upside the head. I personally have a lot of work to do on a couple campaigns as all my best performing keywords are not inactive for search…
So what do we do? Every time one of these come along and I have campaigns affected I first ask myself..
“Does my page serve a good enough purpose for a visitor to stop off there before they go to the merchant… or would they be better off going direct?”
On more then one occasion I’ve had to answer that as ‘no’..
These days I do know the game and I’ve been plugging along just fine.. I have been adding relevant content etc., following their guidelines the best I know how.. But they must have once again tightened some factor up and away I went to $5-10 Minimum Bid requirements on some campaigns.
The ones most affected this time around for me were physical product sites I run.. Product pages and such. It is difficult to say.. to me I feel I’m providing some value, but apparently Google does not now.
But.. what are some things you can try when this happens? Here’s a short list:
- There is an immediate desire to figure out the ‘why’. And there is a strong feeling to make immediate adjustments to try to get it to bounce back. But not so fast.. if you can do it without closing the door completely on what you have now, do it.. but sometimes Google makes mistakes or rolls something out and reverses it.. rolls back those changes; or makes adjustments tweaking the algo. So be careful there; don’t panic!
- As the question I asked above.. does my page make sense - does it add value? And see if there are things you can do to provide more value on that page. Give Google a reason to give you a green light and cheap bids.
- Try playing with your bids. You might be able to raise it up and coax it back down; you never know..
- Play with your ads (but don’t delete any in the process in case you need to roll them back) - you might be able to affect the Quality Score enough to lower those bids..
- Look at your keywords as well.. is there something you can do there? Target them better?.. or differently to pass Google’s test? Can you go the long tail route? Maybe they can be more targeted..
- Consider all the other things you have control of in the Adwords Interface that contribute to the Quality Score
- Review the Landing Page and Site Quality Score Guidelines
- Go Direct to Merchant.. try it.
- And as a last resort, consider starting from scratch on a new domain. Even move what you have currently to a fresh domain.
It’s all crystal clear for the most part right?.. 8O:?
Yes, some of you won’t have it that cut and dried and it won’t be an easy fix. I take the ’stay positive’ roll in this post, but I know when it’s YOUR money that has just been stripped from you that it’s not quite that easy to take it easy and slow.. and not panic.
But know this.. Everyone that I know that has gone through a slap and worked hard, tested their butts off, learned everything they could, applied it.. didn’t give up.. Didn’t get mad and made the necessary adjustments..
..They ALWAYS come back out the other end in better shape.
If you are going to advertise with Adwords, you must know that this is part of the game. A few times a year they are going to make adjustments to their algorithm. If you know and except that, then it’s easier to deal with.
I’ve always gotten excited actually when I’ve read people that were fed up and would never advertise with Google again; it’s music to some of our ears. It frees up some advertising space!
It’s like the move away from ‘Direct to Merchant’ campaigns when the ‘one URL rule’ came about. I loved it! Still do.. you would be surprised how many still make money driving traffic direct to the merchant.
I hope this one didn’t hit you to hard! If it did, just roll up your sleeves and you’ll be back on top in no time! Try and Stay Positive… and Good Luck!
-Matt Levenhagen




October 22nd, 2007 18:03
Good advice, Matt. Especially the bit about not reacting immediately. I suspect that, for most affiliates, more damage is caused by prematurely reacting before they have all the facts and formulate an intelligent plan. Remember, these algorythm changes commonly have a profound change immediately, but then things sometimes relax and bid prices become more reasonable.
Wait and gather info, then act. Good advice, but SO hard to follow when your income gets squeezed.
Jens
October 22nd, 2007 19:38
Hey Jens!
Yep for sure..
It’s a good idea to be careful with that 3rd option too.. playing with bids. Especially if you had a high volume ad group. You could find yourself with a big Google bill within hours if you aren’t careful.
You might simply be stuck at the higher bids now and will need to find ways to increase your CVR with some new advanced methods.. especially if you are up against merchants/authority sites.
-Matt Levenhagen
October 26th, 2007 21:26
Hi Matt,
Is it just me or does Google have it completely backwards? They are going to slap themselves out of business. I don’t think they want to deal with the small publisher anymore, even though we are the ones that help build Google into what it is has become.
With every slap to the small advertiser, it becomes more clear that Google just wants the BIG corporate dollars that don’t care what they spend.
As an advertiser that quantifies everything, I find it offensive that they keep changing the rules for advertisers to conform to some bizzare algorithm.
Editorial Content is organic listings and Adwords are classified ads for crimmany sakes. I don’t think any other medium requires that you supply fresh relevant content on your site in order to place a reasonably priced ad.
Sorry for the mini rant, but it boils my blood everytime this happens because I sell using a simple minisite method and fresh new content doesn’t flow with that too well when you are trying to get the customer to take a specific action.
Thanks,
Rod